.
Feedback

Those Planned Mill Creek Apartment Buildings Are Not a Conspiracy

Get a grip Mill Creekers! This is what happens when you don't pay attention!

The folks in Mill Creek are at it again. I swear they’re just like a bunch of hyperactive toddlers. Leave them alone for 10 seconds and they're riding the labradoodle and climbing the fridge.

Last week, it was the unparalleled horror of having to watch their kindergarten progeny, sad faces plastered against those small square school bus windows, being schlepped 5,280 feet to Fabyan Elementary to mitigate a temporary class size issue.

This week, it’s the prospect of a 390 unit apartment building complex in the northwest corner of that Shodeen paradise that sent them over the edge again.

It’s not that I’m not sympathetic. I am. Why, these dire tribulations remind me of a Big Bang Theory episode where, having to cope with low pulp orange juice that wasn’t and a toaster bent on incineration, Sheldon remarked, “This has to be the worst day of my life.”

These non-Genevans are actually starting to make Eagle Brook look good which is a really difficult thing to do. I haven’t heard this much shrieking and whining since Rush Limbaugh got picked up for drug possession.

“The lack of ownership that an apartment complex would bring is very concerning to all of the residents of Mill Creek,” said one Mill Creek resident.

“A rental community of that size and magnitude does not bring any positives to the community that I can see,” said another, “ I believe it’s a shortsighted solution to the economy with complete disregard to the long-term effects it will bring to the area and the residents who live here.”

Others said something like, “The apartments are not in alignment with the rest of the nearby neighborhood.”

Translated from the original Mill Creek-anese, what that really means is, “We know it’s minorities who tend to rent apartments out here and, while we desperately want those folks to be our bus boys, nannies and landscapers, we really don’t want to have to live with them.”

Not only that, but because some folks think everything should be served up to them on a silver platter, when no one knocked on their door to tell them about this, they automatically assumed it was a done deal borne of the of most heinous of conspiracies.

This is exactly why we need newspapers! The next time you see Jonathan Bilyk or Jim Fuller, you might want to give ‘em a hug for breaking the news.

Did Kent Shodeen, a man who’s as politically connected as it gets, do his darndest to slip this thing in under the radar? You bet he did. Did he do anything illegal or underhanded?

Nope!

The current law stipulates you only have to alert adjacent property owners to an impending development and, since Shodeen Management owns the 1,000 feet of green space between the proposed buildings and the nearest Mill Creek home, all they had to do is warn themselves and Richardson Electronics.

So that’s exactly what he did. Not everything in life is an episode of CSI people!

To make matters worse, one Patch reader wondered aloud what ulterior motive could possibly be behind Shodeen Management’s refusal to hand over those plans which only proves that most people would prefer to spend hours nattering about nefarious plots than take two minutes to call eminently reachable county board member Drew Frasz — which is exactly what I did.

Drew told me the county has already approved 70 townhomes and 210,000 square feet of retail on the parcel located in the northwest corner of the subdivision on Keslinger Road. With the roads already in place, Shodeen could break ground on that project tomorrow.

But they don’t want to do that because, due to our shifting economic environment, evidence suggests that country-based PUDs (Planned Unit Developments) cannot support that kind of hefty commercial enterprise.

“That’s Wal-Mart space and that much retail scares me,” Frasz said, “You really need to put it at a major intersection for it to succeed.”

Ah! But because of the flood of foreclosures and the fact that most homebuyers can’t get a mortgage without submitting one of their children as collateral, the demand for high-end rental units is at unprecedented levels. The parcel in question is also just a stone’s throw from the LaFox Metra station.

So now you can see why Kent Shodeen is rich and you’re not.

But as far as it being a done deal? It ain’t.

As Drew also explained, “When no one from Mill Creek came to the Development Committee or Regional Planning meeting, with 1,000 feet of green space as a buffer, we thought nobody was concerned and voted to move the plan along.”

Once the red flag went up, Frasz asked for the item to be pulled from the Executive Committee agenda and recommended that Shodeen hold a public forum in which Mill Creek residents could have their say.

That meeting will be tonight, July 9, at 7 p.m. in the Mill Creek clubhouse.

Of course, when some Mill Creekers discovered the school board meets at exactly the same time, they immediately started shouting the word “conspiracy” again. Here’s a thought, send your husband to one of them while you attend the other.

Drew also noted this scenario illustrated the need to update the current county notification ordinance. So they’re doing just that. The reworked statute will require a development notice be sent to all property owners within a certain radius as well as public signage.

It’s already on next week’s Development Committee meeting which, of course, none of you will attend. As far as the apartments themselves, nothing moves forward until it’s approved by the full county board.

“Shodeen has a great history of managing properties,” Frasz said, “It (the open space) won’t stay a cornfield and it won’t be a park. You have do decide what you really want to go in there”

Frasz finished with this insight, “By and large, there are a lot of really reasonable people in Mill Creek. Like we did in LaFox, they need to work with Shodeen to come up with something that’s palatable to everyone.”

Apparently Frasz has a much higher opinion of Mill Creekers than I do. Considering their recent track record, I’m actually starting to feel sorry for Kent Shodeen. And that’s something I never thought I’d say.

Chris July 11, 2012 at 02:28 pm
AMEN!!!! FINISH BUILDING THE "PLANNED" UNITS IN THE VILLAGE CENTER BEFORE YOU START ANOTHER PROJECT!!!
Why the big rush to start another project when the Village Center in Mill Creek has gone unfinished for years??? Finish what is planned 1st then go on from there....
Jeff Ward July 11, 2012 at 02:32 pm
Katie, Katie, Katie,
Please note that I said you pay no taxes "to the City of Geneva." The schools, libraries, and parks are always their own entities and, especially out here in the boonies, their boundaries tend to range far afield. And my point wasn't that you couldn't vote (thank God!), it was that, as long as you live in Mill Creek, you will never be able to vote for a Geneva alderman or mayor. Again, one of Mayor Burns favorite things is when one of you geography addled mill creekers threaten to vote him out of office. His somewhat less snarky response is always something along the lines of, "good luck with that!" Jeff
Chris July 11, 2012 at 02:48 pm
Jeff...
Were you at the meeting in Mill Creek on Monday???
Jeff Ward July 11, 2012 at 02:52 pm
Chris,
No! I value my life. I did get the full rundown from Drew Frasz and some of the reporters that were. Jeff
J.O. July 11, 2012 at 05:44 pm
If Mill Creek isn't in Geneva - why are you expressing an opinion on it? This is the Geneva Patch - not the Blackberry Township Patch.
Matilda B July 11, 2012 at 07:13 pm
I thought Eaglebrook was within the City limits? Don't you have an alderman?
Jeff Ward July 11, 2012 at 07:24 pm
Matilda,
Eaglebook is indeed in Geneva. Though it's not part of Mill Creek, they too think they're a step above the rest of Geneva. Jeff
Chris July 11, 2012 at 08:08 pm
Jeff...you are such a tool...I don't blame you for hiding your face in Mill Creek.  I've never seen someone throw an entire community under the bus simply because of where they live. You have a record of showing your true racism. 
Jeff Ward July 11, 2012 at 08:26 pm
Chris,
If I could literally throw them under the school bus, I would! And you've finally ferreted it out! I'm biased against white folks! Jeff
peter D July 11, 2012 at 10:25 pm
Jeff,
Evanston is a terrible place to live and grow up.....The people who come from that city are all dirt bags..... Ooops did I just stereotype everyone that lived in Evanston? I sound like you Jeff. You make Archie Bunker look like a boy scout...
Jeff Ward July 11, 2012 at 10:32 pm
Peter,
No! You have that wrong. Archie Bunker would want to live in Mill Creek! Jeff
angela July 12, 2012 at 11:24 am
Hey Jeff why so bitter? We here in Mill Creek purchased these homes and have every right to have a say in what multi-purpose properties.; whether apartments or commercial business is built in our neighborhood. We personally had our kids living in Humbolt Park in downtown Chicago before we came out here. We are not racist and we welcome diversity. We just want to raise our kids in a safe place. Pretty simple. It isn't a race thing..... it is a business transaction that could have certain resale consequences for us in the future. BUSINESS. You are a ignorant jerk. I love the class warfare tone. Very positive! You don't know all the people that live in Mill Creek and you have no place to judge.
Jeff Ward July 12, 2012 at 12:00 pm
Angela,
Why don't you say what you really feel about me next time? It's in the words that Mill Creekers resort to. Instead of using rational arguments against the apartments like water infrastructure and traffic issues, they employ terms like, "not taking ownership," "more crime," and "low income." And we all know what that really means. And I keep trying to tell you folks that I'm an opinion columnist who gets paid to pass judgment! Jeff
John Doe July 12, 2012 at 07:03 pm
The tone of this discussion is disturbing.
Mr. Ward, I agree that the path to success is being rational. Mill Creekers, I agree the apartments are a bad idea. Your school is already near capacity, you do NOT have a local police department, and something like this does not belong on a rural road, however; "you know what that brings..." is a lame argument. Mr Ward, I do not understand why you are taking liberties for entertainment and not helpfulness. I also do not understand the connection to Eagle Brook. I live in neither, but if you are cleverly accusing Mill Creekers and those in Eagle Brook for snobbery, It appears to me you are doing the same. Prejudices go up and down the food chain, you know.
Kimberly Kozar July 12, 2012 at 07:21 pm
So, how did the meeting go - from the residents perspective? You all know I've been involved in communication within the Mill Creek community for many years and I will go on record for saying from the very first issue of the Mill Creek Messenger, organized communication is key! I encourage the same in my work place and my family. You guys have to get it together, Jeff has given you some valuable insight as to how you can methodically and reasonably make your voice heard. Just like most communities, there are many amazing, talented, and wise business oriented as well as creative minds in Mill Creek. Put it to good use, get organized and you will find you have a very powerful influence on policy and decisions within your community. You have the ability to smooth out the many bumps you have yet to face in the roads of Mill Creek's future. The first thing I'd do, is get Ken Loebel to run as Mill Creek Mayor!
ken loebel July 12, 2012 at 07:36 pm
If we are only a measley commonwealth then could the title be Super Mayor?
Brian Schneden July 12, 2012 at 08:25 pm
Jeff,
Methinks thy paint brush is too large.
Kimberly Kozar July 12, 2012 at 08:40 pm
I suppose the next thing you'll ask for is a cape!
Jeff Ward July 12, 2012 at 08:47 pm
John,
Perhaps a suggestion to lighten up might not be a bad idea. The only reason I mentioned Eagle Brook is because of Ken L's whimsical posts. Well, that and they have an entitlement mentality as big as Montana. Sometimes, mirroring behavior is the best way to make a point! Jeff
Jeff Ward July 12, 2012 at 08:49 pm
Kim,
You've caught on to the really ironic thing here. Though I'm giving these folks the keys to the fighting city hall kingdom, they'd rather focus on me and my liberal (pun intended) use of hyperbole. Killing the messenger is always so much more fun than looking in the mirror. Even though I can't vote in Mill Creek, in the true and traditional Chicago style, I'll be voting for him at least four times! Jeff
Jeff Ward July 12, 2012 at 08:50 pm
Ken,
Should my long-suffering editor assent, my next column will encourage Mill Creek to secede from the union. So, forget about mayor, I'll personally nominate you for king of Millcreekia! Jeff
Jeff Ward July 12, 2012 at 08:51 pm
Brian,
Sadly, when it comes to Mill Creek - and Geneva in general - it's not nearly large enough! Jeff
Sandy Kaczmarski July 12, 2012 at 11:24 pm
The last comment was deleted because of profanity. Unnecessary. C'mon folks, let's be civil.
Peter D July 13, 2012 at 12:20 am
Jeff,
I wonder what neighborhood Jeff lives in and what year the home was built..... It would be funny if he lived in one Mr. Schodeen's original Geneva developments. Jeff care to answer or are you afraid of pitch forks and torches rushing to your front door?
Jeff Ward July 13, 2012 at 12:33 am
Peter,
No problem! My first Geneva house was built by Joe Keim in Pepper Valley and I regret moving out of it. It was and probably will be the best constructed house I'll ever live in. The second Geneva house was built by Kimball Hill who were such complete morons they went out of business. I would prefer a Shodeen house to anything Kimball Hill has ever built - but that's not setting the bar too high. Jeff
dave July 14, 2012 at 10:10 pm
Jeff the last time I entered Mill Creek I miss the sign that proclaimed only like minded white Republicans are allowed past is point. The sign went on the say the only exceptions being allowed are if you are here to mow someones grass, clean a pool, collect the garbage, deliver the Geneva Republican, drop off our school children or here clean one of the many mansions.
You may think that this is to much to put on one sign, maybe overkill. Lets get succinct. NO DEMOCRATS ALLOWED!!!
ken loebel July 15, 2012 at 12:57 pm
For the 75% of the population that believes the old 2 party system is corrupted, ourdated, and rigged... independents THRIVE in Mill Creek...just need to be careful about the left and right extremists!
Paul ruby July 17, 2012 at 10:48 am
Ken,
You have my vote.
ken loebel July 17, 2012 at 01:10 pm
Super Mayor declares today is Mill Creek Tuesday! Celebrate safely and keep cool! Let'all do a Mill Creek Rain Dance...in Mill Creek style!
ken loebel July 20, 2012 at 01:52 am
Rain dance worked - now let's do a property tax reduction dance!

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Geneva Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
Tom Brown June 14, 2013 at 10:18 am
I notice that too! Wonder where the actual polling place will be.
Martha Hanna June 13, 2013 at 07:48 am
Good! Hultgren is a troll!
Matilda B June 13, 2013 at 12:38 pm
Count me in. I should already be on their email list. He needs to go.
Jessica Chipkin June 13, 2013 at 10:58 pm
Martha -- please email us if you aren't on our list. turn14blue@gmail.com
Basale
Geneva Vikings June 10, 2013 at 10:28 am
We have 24 hours to find a foster for these babies! We are pulling 8 from this Animal ControlRead More Facility and would love to rescue these 5 tiny pups too. Fostering is an amazing experience for your entire family and Casey's SAfe Haven pays all of the costs to foster. We provide food, vet care, crate, puppy playpen, toys, etc. You provide plenty of love, socialization and since they are puppies we hope you have a lot of newspaper! Please email Kathy at caseysdogs@yahoo.com
Fred Cregier June 11, 2013 at 02:11 pm
I have to agree with the others who are disappointed with the new format of Patch. The old versionRead More had more zip and more interesting topics. Now it has become very blah! I am sorry but change is not always a good thing. Fred Cregier
Arthur Dietrich June 12, 2013 at 08:23 am
The link provided by LW Sagan explains why the Patch is becoming irrelevant and that is a shame. IRead More don't even think Rick Nagel can save it.
Fred Cregier June 12, 2013 at 08:52 am
Chris, I have another story of waste in the County to add to your fix-it lists: We received,Read More yesterday, our new voters registration cards from John Cunningham's office, telling us that our polling place will be Coultrap School (which has been the case previously for many years). The problem is that Coultrap School is currently being demolished! So, who pays for having to send out corrections on this? Is Cunningham's office that insulated from what is going on in the real world? Fred Cregier