Geneva
Current Weather
- Today
- 48°
- Local every day in
As inexplicably as it all started, it appears to be as inexplicably over. And I say “appears” because, when it comes to the Geneva teachers union, nothing surprises me anymore.
Though I’m convinced the teachers will ratify the as-yet-undisclosed contract agreement the day this column runs, it wouldn’t surprise me if the union leaders had one more trick up their sleeve.
And I keep repeating the word “surprise” because that’s the only word that adequately describes this dynamic from the day it started until late last Monday night. But let’s move on before we unintentionally court any further Swiftian ironies.
Since we’re on the subject of surprises, the one pleasant surprise to come out of all this consternation is you—the citizens of Geneva.
If, two short years ago, you told me this city would present a virtually united front in the face of a seriously divisive issue, I would’ve told your significant other to lock up the liquor cabinet.
And some of that public opinion groundswell happened right here on Patch.
When you consider all the anti-teacher sentiment out there—something I never have and never will condone—I thought the vast majority of you kept your commentary within the bounds of rhetorical reason. And you did so despite the online union supporters who seemed to be doing their best to inflame the situation (a tactic perhaps?)
Not only that, but you kept the absurdly pointless conspiracy theories to a reasonable minimum. Take it from someone who’s been there, far more often than not, political groups operate on a “where the wind blows” behavioral model.
The best proof of good conduct is the Nov. 5 School Board meeting. Add 200 picketing teachers to an even greater number of disenfranchised parents, and I truly believed all hell was going to break loose.
My impetus for attending that gathering was something along the lines of going to a NASCAR race to see the crashes, but it never happened.
When GEA President Carol Young’s husband addressed the board and casually mentioned the two Geneva homes they own, I wanted to dive under the press table and shout, “incoming!” That had to be the most ill-advised “appeal” I’ve ever heard.
But instead, the few pro-board speakers who followed him made me proud to be a Genevan. And the rest of the crowd politely listened and reasonably applauded when moved to do so.
I also want to thank all the respectful readers who approached me that evening, especially Gail Ryan, who proved that disagreement doesn’t mean you attack someone on sight. I have to say she was exceptionally gracious.
Bob McQuillan’s poetic Patch commentary to the tune of Edwin Starr’s signature song War notwithstanding, even FACTS seemed to know when to zip it this round. With the vast pro-board presence speaking so much louder than words, they wisely chose not to speak. And they generally kept the online excrement down, too.
If FACTS continues to demonstrate this capacity to understand when to wisely withhold comment (something I seriously doubt), then I will be happy to return the favor.
But as much as you all impressed me, the folks who truly earned my admiration were those who serve on our School Board. Please allow me name each one: Mark Grosso, Tim Moran, Matt Henry, Kelly Nowak, Mary Stith, Bill Wilson and Mike McCormick.
Though this volunteer group held all of the political capital, instead of turning these negotiations into the kind of rout that would’ve haunted this district for decades, they kept their mouths shut and held their heads high when the best of us would’ve taken no prisoners.
By their leadership, they showed this city that you can stick to your principles, be respectful, AND still work your way through one of the most contentious set of circumstances we’ll ever see. If it weren’t a clear case of cruel and unusual punishment, I think we oughtta send ‘em to Washington.
Ah! But, it ain’t all wine and roses! There’s one more step we need to take.
Parent-teacher conferences are coming, and I’ve heard the rumblings about using that opportunity to provide the proverbial piece of your mind. While it would be disingenuous for me to discourage anyone from speaking their truth, that doesn’t preclude me from encouraging you to keep the board’s fine example in mind if you choose to do so.
Please remember that there’s a clear distinction between the union and the teachers.
You’ve made me proud, Geneva! Keep it up!
Robert Jr.
7:11 am on Wednesday, November 14, 2012
I agree with your observations - thanks for putting on the Patch. I totally agree with the comments towards the hard work on the Board. I would just add that rather than view it as an us vs. them, and winner vs. loser, we discuss it as an acknowledgement of the difficult times we all face, and that we all need to sacrifice together, now and in the future. It is not a community vs. a union and teachers, it is a community that includes unions and people who have chosen to be professional educators. We need to share in sacrifice and share in growth. Right now is a time to sacrifice and also to stand together as a community, not a community divided.
I would add that the comments about Bob McQuillan over the past year have gone from radically condemning him in the Patch to applauding him ... and he deserves accolades for providing information and collecting the information that became a central point of discussion during this process. Thanks Bob.
Most importantly, thanks to the students who continued to go to classes, observe the events taking place, and keep their focus... this was a real life lesson in a world that is not always smiles, texts, and parties. But in the end, we find a way to have reasonable disagreements and it is a good thing for students to see democracy in action - it demonstrates what civic participation is all about, which is one of the missions from the IEA/GEA.
Show Me The $$
11:40 am on Wednesday, November 14, 2012
@Robert Jr. Well written commentary.
My only addition to this would be if the contract is signed and approved, and before the ink is dry, the BOE should begin the search for other alternatives for teaching in District 304.
Perform due diligence. All other public entities submit Request for Proposals for services. I strongly urge District 304 to do the same during the next 3 years.
This will educate the BOE on other options that may exist and use the best proposal as a bargaining tool if the GEA contract is not in the best interest of the taxpayers.
If the BOE cannot come to an agreement with the GEA during contract negotiations, they will then have alternatives that may be better for the District 304 community.
Public Act 094-0881
Sec. 10-16.5. Oath of office. Each school board member, before taking his or her seat on the board, shall take an oath of office in substantially the following form:
I shall respect taxpayer interests by serving as a faithful protector of the school district's assets;
I shall encourage and respect the free expression of opinion by my fellow board members and others who seek a hearing before the board, while respecting the privacy of students and employees;
DJP
9:12 am on Wednesday, November 14, 2012
@RobertJr: Please share what are the teachers sacrificing? My property taxes will go up over $340 next year and the teachers salaries and benefits will increase. What other private organizations are increasing benefits and salaries in this economy?
Who is paying their FAIR share and Who is not? Hmmmmmmmmmm
Jeff Ward
10:00 am on Wednesday, November 14, 2012
Dear Readers,
Apparently the teachers union is unhappy with yours truly and they've gone to the Chronicle to complain about what a heinous cad I truly am.
You can read that story right here: http://thefirstward.net/2012/11/14/the-union-strikes-back/
Jeff
Ken Schuman
3:33 pm on Wednesday, November 14, 2012
Jeff, while I'm not sure I could argue the heinous cad comment it looks to me like the marketing geniuses the union employed for their contract negotiations are still on the job.
Grace F
6:34 am on Thursday, November 15, 2012
Nice article, Jeff. The individual teachers, however, do make up the union. That said, I will be nice at conferences. I agree with you ShowMe. The Board is listening to the community and if we feel like the levy should be 0% (which I think will still mean a small increase) instead of the 1.5%, we need to email and let them know. Property values will fall further the more ridiculous our taxes get.